The Microsoft Surface Book 3 (15-Inch) Review: A Refreshing Dip Into Ice Lake
by Brett Howse on June 3, 2020 9:00 AM ESTFinal Words
The Surface Book 3 delivers a solid refresh to Microsoft's detachable laptop family, offering more of almost everything. There is more performance thanks to the new Core i7-1065G7 and GeForce GTX 1660 Ti. There is more RAM thanks to the switch to LPDDR4X. The new 10 nm processor provides better battery life. The Wi-Fi is much improved thanks to the new Intel AX201 Wi-Fi 6 adapter. Even the USB ports got an upgrade to USB 3.2 Gen 2, while the Surface Connect port now offers the same 3.2 Gen 2 speeds along with DisplayPort 1.4 for dual-UHD external monitor support. If you loved the idea of the Surface Book 2 but thought it was a bit long in the tooth or otherwise underpowered, the new Surface Book 3 delivers all of the upgrades needed to keep it a proper current generation notebook.
Surface devices have always offered a great build quality, and the Surface Book 3 continues that legacy with its magnesium alloy chassis. Microsoft has improved the undocking mechanism to make it faster, and improvements to DirectX 12 mean that the system is finally able to automatically migrate active workloads from the discrete GPU to the integrated one when detaching, at least as long as the active application supports this.
The Surface Book 3, like the Surface Book 2, offers one of the best typing experiences on any notebook, and couples it with one of the best trackpads around. The display is still identical to the outgoing model, but that display is also one of the best available on a notebook, so it is hard to fault them for keeping it.
Microsoft still includes 1080p video recording support, with a 5 MP front facing camera and 8 MP rear facing camera, and coupled with the dual far-field microphones makes the Surface Book 3 an ideal, if somewhat overpowered, video conferencing device.
There is no denying that the upgrades have worked well. If there was a complaint, it would be that this is now the third generation of more or less the same design, and while a design that is still impressive, it also is showing its age. The large display bezels, while partially required due to the convertible nature of the Surface Book, stand out in a premium device in 2020. The lack of Thunderbolt 3 support is also an increasingly glaring omission when all of their competitors offer it. It took Microsoft a long time to adopt USB Type-C for reasons only they seem to understand, and while it is nice to finally have that, a universal docking solution over Thunderbolt 3 would serve them well.
The Surface Book 3 still does fulfill its role though as a very powerful laptop, built with premium materials, and offering some unique features. The upgrades for 2020 were necessary to keep the design relevant, even if is relatively unchanged on the outside. The new configuration options, especially the ability to purchase it with 32 GB of RAM, opens up the device to those who need a lot of RAM for their workflows, and being able to purchase it with Quadro RTX also opens the door to some new mobile workstation use cases. Surface Book is never going to be the sales leader in the Surface lineup, mostly due to the price, but there is no denying that it is still one of the best notebooks on the market.
125 Comments
View All Comments
YB1064 - Wednesday, June 3, 2020 - link
I own the original Surface Book (i5) with the NVidia GPU. Still going strong after all these years. Apart from the mediocre keyboard, I have no complaints. It would be nice if Anandtech can add those numbers to the comparison charts.Brett Howse - Thursday, June 4, 2020 - link
You can always use our Bench to compare anything. Link in the article as well as at the top of the page:https://www.anandtech.com/bench/product/2599?vs=15...
Our tests have changed so it will only show data where both ran the same test.
YB1064 - Friday, June 5, 2020 - link
Thank you Brett, I forgot about that.blaktron - Wednesday, June 3, 2020 - link
This review really highlights how good a value the Acer Swift 3 this generation, at like 1/2 to 1/3 the price of the cheapest Surface Book or Laptop. Both the Intel and AMD versions.Redshirt4life - Wednesday, June 3, 2020 - link
"This Mercedes S-class review really highlights what a great value the Honda Civic is!" - you, probably.blaktron - Wednesday, June 3, 2020 - link
If the Civic blew circles around the Mercedes, then yeah. That's exactly what I would say.Flunk - Wednesday, June 3, 2020 - link
Civic Type-R? On a track => smoked S-Class.It's not hard to find examples of cars that are much cheaper than an S-Class that can run circles around one. But it's just as irrelevant a comparison as comparing this to an Acer Swift 3. Which is the point the previous posted was making.
FunBunny2 - Wednesday, June 3, 2020 - link
does a Patek Philippe keep better time than a Seiko? either mainspring or quartz??devione - Friday, June 5, 2020 - link
Actually a COSC-certified Patek does probably keep better time than a Seiko.Please, (in general, not just you) stop with the internet car analogies (or watches). It's stupid.
close - Friday, June 5, 2020 - link
Well analogies are never perfect, they just have to be good enough to make a point. And in this case they still can. Even when much of that price is "the brand" you still get objective benefits that might make you choose the more expensive option. Very rarely are 2 products absolutely identical except for the logo which make one 2 times more expensive. You'll get better performance, better features, better build quality, better reliability, better feel, better support and services, etc. Any one of those can justify the price.Right next to me I have a 2008 Lenovo X200 which I used every day for the first 6 years and every week since then. Traveled with it through an airport almost every week of those first 6 years. It looks like new, it works like new. Yes it was probably 4-5 times more expensive than the equivalent Acer but under these conditions I would have probably had to buy 6 Acers to keep up.
Usually things have a certain price for a reason. At least in part you get what you pay for. If this works for you go for it.